| Rank | Name | YOB | Club | Split | Time | Chiptime | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fannar Baldursson | ISL | 1974 |
00:39:17 (5 mile) |
01:16:44 | 01:16:39 | ||
| 2 | David Bolan | USA | 1972 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:41:40 (5 mile) |
01:26:52 | +10:08 | 01:26:51 |
| 3 | Þorgeir Jóhannes Kjartansson | ISL | 1971 | Hlaupahópur VSB |
00:44:44 (5 mile) |
01:29:23 | +12:39 | 01:29:17 |
| 4 | Georg Lúðvíksson | ISL | 1976 |
00:47:44 (5 mile) |
01:34:04 | +17:20 | 01:33:59 | |
| 5 | Kristopher Madaus | USA | 1974 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:47:52 (5 mile) |
01:35:46 | +19:02 | 01:35:38 |
| 6 | Óskar Helgi Guðnason | ISL | 1972 | Frískir Flóamenn |
00:51:33 (5 mile) |
01:40:11 | +23:27 | 01:40:09 |
| 7 | Griffin Kisner | USA | 1973 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:47:39 (5 mile) |
01:42:19 | +25:35 | 01:42:14 |