| Rank | Name | YOB | Club | Split | Time | Chiptime | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jonathan Slater | USA | 1969 | Marathon Expedtions |
00:39:17 (5 mile) |
01:14:10 | 01:14:07 | |
| 2 | Rúnar Sigurðsson | ISL | 1964 |
00:39:18 (5 mile) |
01:15:46 | +01:36 | 01:15:42 | |
| 3 | Friðrik Ármann Guðmundsson | ISL | 1960 | Hlaupasamtök Lýðveldisins |
00:40:18 (5 mile) |
01:19:14 | +05:04 | 01:19:12 |
| 4 | Sævar Gunnarsson | ISL | 1968 | Frískir Flóamenn |
00:41:22 (5 mile) |
01:20:31 | +06:21 | 01:20:29 |
| 5 | Anthony Widdicombe | USA | 1962 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:40:19 (5 mile) |
01:20:31 | +06:21 | 01:20:28 |
| 6 | Steven Swift | USA | 1965 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:42:21 (5 mile) |
01:23:21 | +09:11 | 01:23:19 |
| 7 | Bárður Árnason | ISL | 1965 |
00:44:14 (5 mile) |
01:27:01 | +12:51 | 01:26:59 | |
| 8 | Lúðvík Elíasson | ISL | 1969 |
00:43:29 (5 mile) |
01:27:33 | +13:23 | 01:27:30 | |
| 9 | Bob Ehardt | USA | 1963 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:43:26 (5 mile) |
01:29:13 | +15:03 | 01:29:08 |
| 10 | Michael McNett | USA | 1965 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:49:31 (5 mile) |
01:40:01 | +25:51 | 01:39:59 |
| 11 | Michael Murphree | USA | 1960 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:51:50 (5 mile) |
01:45:13 | +31:03 | 01:45:09 |
| 12 | Tim Robinson | USA | 1962 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:54:02 (5 mile) |
01:46:40 | +32:30 | 01:46:32 |
| 13 | Vigfús Eyjólfsson | ISL | 1967 | Frískir flóamenn |
01:00:50 (5 mile) |
01:52:40 | +38:30 | 01:52:39 |
| 14 | Greg Segner | USA | 1963 | Marathon Expeditions |
00:59:14 (5 mile) |
02:02:18 | +48:08 | 02:02:10 |
| 15 | Glen Bruckner | USA | 1965 | Marathon Expeditions |
01:02:07 (5 mile) |
02:10:27 | +56:17 | 02:10:20 |