| Rank | BIB | Name | Year | Club | Split | Time | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 372 | Þorlákur Jónsson | 1965 | KR-skokk | 00:32:33 (5 mile) | 01:04:23 | |
| 2 | 377 | Sigurður Tómas Þórisson | 1977 | 00:33:54 (5 mile) | 01:06:40 | +02:17 | |
| 3 | 376 | Einar Sigurjónsson | 1980 | Ægir3 | 00:35:25 (5 mile) | 01:09:27 | +05:04 |
| 4 | 341 | Erlendur Steinn Guðnason | 1972 | KR-skokk | 00:37:02 (5 mile) | 01:11:57 | +07:34 |
| 5 | 360 | Pelle Damby Caroee | 1987 | 00:36:09 (5 mile) | 01:12:02 | +07:39 | |
| 6 | 342 | Friðrik Ármann Guðmundsson | 1960 | Hlaupasamtök Lýðveldisins | 00:37:26 (5 mile) | 01:13:09 | +08:46 |
| 7 | 353 | Ívar Trausti Jósafatsson | 1961 | Komaso | 00:35:51 (5 mile) | 01:13:09 | +08:46 |
| 8 | 331 | Alexander Örn Númason | 1993 | 00:39:15 (5 mile) | 01:14:18 | +09:55 | |
| 9 | 327 | Markús Andri Sigurðsson | 1992 | 00:38:08 (5 mile) | 01:14:59 | +10:36 | |
| 10 | 345 | Haraldur Haraldsson | 1966 | KR-Skokk | 00:38:27 (5 mile) | 01:15:42 | +11:19 |
| 11 | 340 | Einar Arnarsson | 1963 | KR-skokk | 00:37:52 (5 mile) | 01:16:54 | +12:31 |
| 12 | 351 | Hrólfur Gestsson | 1969 | KR Skokk | 00:39:09 (5 mile) | 01:19:13 | +14:50 |
| 13 | 337 | Bjarki Þór Pálmason | 1983 | 00:38:14 (5 mile) | 01:19:24 | +15:01 | |
| 14 | 357 | Ólafur Frímann Kristjánsson | 1994 | 00:41:00 (5 mile) | 01:19:56 | +15:33 | |
| 15 | 344 | Guðmundur Lúther Hallgrímsson | 1987 | Gengið | 00:42:23 (5 mile) | 01:23:03 | +18:40 |
| 16 | 373 | Þorvaldur Ingimundarson | 1970 | Hlaupahópur Ármanns | 00:43:02 (5 mile) | 01:26:18 | +21:55 |
| 17 | 338 | Bjarni Magnússon | 1980 | KR-skokk | 00:46:22 (5 mile) | 01:30:12 | +25:49 |
| 18 | 348 | Helgi Hjartarson | 1968 | 00:47:04 (5 mile) | 01:30:50 | +26:27 | |
| 19 | 371 | Þorfinnur Skúlason | 1971 | KR-skokk | 00:44:54 (5 mile) | 01:31:19 | +26:56 |
| 20 | 365 | Sigurjón Njarðarson | 1979 | 00:46:42 (5 mile) | 01:31:36 | +27:13 | |
| 21 | 328 | Reynir Grétar Jónsson | 1987 | 00:46:03 (5 mile) | 01:31:44 | +27:21 | |
| 22 | 364 | Sigmundur Stefánsson | 1953 | Frískir Flóamenn | 00:46:01 (5 mile) | 01:32:14 | +27:51 |
| 23 | 349 | Hermann Ólafsson | 1968 | Frískir flóamenn | 00:46:03 (5 mile) | 01:32:14 | +27:51 |
| 24 | 380 | Hróbjartur Eyjólfsson | 1966 | 00:46:41 (5 mile) | 01:32:41 | +28:18 | |
| 25 | 375 | Baldur Tumi Baldurssin | 1959 | Hlaupasamtök Lýðveldisins | 00:46:24 (5 mile) | 01:35:29 | +31:06 |
| 26 | 374 | Þórður Eiríksson | 1959 | Skokkhópur Fram | 00:47:31 (5 mile) | 01:36:21 | +31:58 |
| 27 | 339 | Björn Magnússon | 1947 | Frískir Flóamenn | 00:48:36 (5 mile) | 01:37:51 | +33:28 |
| 28 | 350 | Hermann Þór Baldursson | 1965 | 00:49:44 (5 mile) | 01:38:51 | +34:28 | |
| 29 | 358 | Óskar Andreasen | 1972 | Frískir Flóamenn | 00:49:55 (5 mile) | 01:39:52 | +35:29 |
| 30 | 332 | Andrés Yngvi Jóakimsson | 1971 | Náttúruhlaup | 00:49:54 (5 mile) | 01:39:52 | +35:29 |
| 31 | 378 | Vigfús Eyjólfsson | 1967 | Frískir Flóamenn | 00:53:17 (5 mile) | 01:50:12 | +45:49 |