| Rank | BIB | Name | Year | Club | NAT | Split | Time | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 9 | Sveinbjörn Orri Heimisson | 2003 | SFÍ | IS | 00:27:59 (Búrfell 1) 00:49:43 (Heiðin) 01:12:41 (Búrfell 2) 01:31:05 (Miðfellsháls) | 01:49:44 | ||
| 2 | 10 | Ástmar Helgi Kristinsson | 2005 | SFÍ | IS | 00:33:40 (Búrfell 1) 01:00:41 (Heiðin) 01:28:16 (Búrfell 2) 01:53:19 (Miðfellsháls) | 02:15:22 | +25:38 | |
| 3 | 23 | Grétar Smári Samúelsson | 2006 | IS | 00:35:02 (Búrfell 1) 01:04:29 (Heiðin) 01:34:19 (Búrfell 2) 01:57:13 (Miðfellsháls) | 02:17:33 | +27:49 | ||
| 4 | 15 | Benedikt Stefánsson | 2006 | SFÍ | IS | 00:37:01 (Búrfell 1) 01:10:22 (Heiðin) 01:43:53 (Búrfell 2) 02:07:56 (Miðfellsháls) | 02:28:24 | +38:40 | |
| 5 | 88 | Ólafur Örn Guðmundsson | 1993 | IS | 00:42:24 (Búrfell 1) 01:14:08 (Heiðin) 01:50:47 (Búrfell 2) 02:19:52 (Miðfellsháls) | 02:48:53 | +59:09 | ||
| 6 | 85 | Vilmar Ben Hallgrímsson | 1998 | Team Dynjandi | IS | 00:45:14 (Búrfell 1) 01:17:16 (Heiðin) 01:55:56 (Búrfell 2) 02:25:45 (Miðfellsháls) | 02:52:10 | +01:02:26 | |
| 7 | 81 | Bjarni Heimisson | 1991 | FC öööööö | IS | 00:47:28 (Búrfell 1) 01:28:15 (Heiðin) 02:05:34 (Búrfell 2) 02:37:56 (Miðfellsháls) | 03:06:02 | +01:16:18 | |
| 8 | 90 | Tyler Wacker | 1990 | Nordic Narwhals | US | 00:50:02 (Búrfell 1) 01:33:30 (Heiðin) 02:14:30 (Búrfell 2) 02:47:26 (Miðfellsháls) | 03:25:41 | +01:35:57 | |
| 9 | 93 | Steingrímur Páll Þórðarson | 1988 | IS | 00:57:04 (Búrfell 1) 01:46:15 (Heiðin) 02:30:10 (Búrfell 2) 03:09:42 (Miðfellsháls) | 03:41:43 | +01:51:59 |