| Rank | Bib | Name | Club | Year | Split | Time | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2000 | Arnar Ólafsson | SKA | 2000 | 00:30:31 (6,0 km) 00:50:57 (9,5 km) | 01:26:48 | .. |
| 2 | 2001 | Jakob Danielsson | Skíðafélag ísafjarðar | 2001 | 00:32:06 (6,0 km) 00:54:10 (9,5 km) | 01:33:11 | .. |
| 3 | 2005 | Daníel Jakobsson | Riddarar Rósu | 1973 | 00:32:53 (6,0 km) 00:55:07 (9,5 km) | 01:33:13 | .. |
| 4 | 2003 | Benedikt Sigurðsson | UMFB | 1975 | 00:35:57 (6,0 km) 01:01:08 (9,5 km) | 01:40:05 | .. |
| 5 | 2002 | Árni Friðrik Guðmundsson | Laugaskokk | 2005 | 00:45:35 (6,0 km) 01:20:16 (9,5 km) | 02:14:07 | .. |
| 6 | 2008 | Gudmundur heimir sveinbjörnsson | Laugaskokk | 1974 | 00:45:34 (6,0 km) 01:20:18 (9,5 km) | 02:14:07 | .. |