| Rank | Bib | Name | Club | Year | Split | Time | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1316 | Gísli Einar Árnason | Hlaupafélagið Kári | 1974 | 00:29:29 (6,5 km) | 00:50:57 | .. |
| 2 | 1306 | Egill Bjarni Gíslason | Hlaupafélagið Kári | 2001 | 00:30:34 (6,5 km) | 00:58:47 | .. |
| 3 | 1325 | Samúel Stefánsson | SFÍ | 1982 | 00:36:58 (6,5 km) | 01:04:33 | .. |
| 4 | 1301 | Kristinn Gunnarsson | Hlaupahóður HK | 1959 | 00:38:40 (6,5 km) | 01:05:57 | .. |
| 5 | 1305 | Kristbjörn Róbert Sigurjónsson | Team Craft/Riddarar Rósu | 1960 | 00:43:08 (6,5 km) | 01:11:50 | .. |
| 6 | 1326 | Ólafur Pétur Eyþórsson | 2003 | 00:42:44 (6,5 km) | 01:12:19 | .. | |
| 7 | 1321 | Haraldur Gunnarsson | Árbæjarskokk | 1960 | 00:43:08 (6,5 km) | 01:12:26 | .. |
| 8 | 1314 | Guðmundur Gunnarsson | Karlakórinn Esja | 1976 | 00:43:51 (6,5 km) | 01:13:11 | .. |
| 9 | 1302 | Ketill Már Björnsson | Skagaskokk | 1963 | 00:46:01 (6,5 km) | 01:16:27 | .. |
| 10 | 1320 | Jón Páll Hreinsson | Bolungarvík | 1973 | 00:46:26 (6,5 km) | 01:16:55 | .. |
| 11 | 1322 | Sveinbjörn Orri Heimisson | SFÍ | 2003 | 00:52:45 (6,5 km) | 01:36:38 | .. |
| 12 | 1323 | Örnólfur Oddson | Riddarar Rósu/ÍR | 1956 | 00:38:23 (6,5 km) | DNF | .. |