| Rank | BIB | Name | Year | Club | Split | Time | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 839 | Kristinn Jónsson | 2000 | HFR | 00:23:52 (1) 00:24:30 (2) 00:25:27 (3) 00:25:45 (4) | 01:39:31.60 | ||
| 2 | 838 | Davíð Jónsson | 2004 | HFR | 00:24:08 (1) 00:25:55 (2) 00:26:06 (3) 00:26:15 (4) | 01:42:21.94 | +02:50 | |
| 3 | 836 | Dennis van Eijk | 1987 | Tindur | 00:24:52 (1) 00:26:02 (2) 00:25:39 (3) 00:26:52 (4) | 01:43:22.71 | +03:51 | |
| 4 | 822 | Guðmundur Sveinsson | 1979 | Breiðablik | 00:24:55 (1) 00:25:59 (2) 00:26:16 (3) 00:27:11 (4) | 01:44:19.76 | +04:48 | |
| 5 | 840 | Bjarki Bjarnason | 1984 | HFR | 00:25:49 (1) 00:25:49 (2) 00:26:29 (3) 00:27:01 (4) | 01:45:05.71 | +05:34 | |
| 6 | 826 | Ármann Gylfason | 1977 | HFR | 00:26:58 (1) 00:27:27 (2) 00:28:32 (3) 00:28:24 (4) | 01:51:19.44 | +11:48 | |
| 7 | 828 | Breki Gunnarsson | 2004 | HFR | 00:26:01 (1) 00:29:37 (2) 00:29:44 (3) 00:28:33 (4) | 01:53:53.28 | +14:22 | |
| 8 | 805 | Tómas Kári Björgvinsson Rist | 2005 | BFH | 00:48:42 (1) |