| Rank | BIB | Name | Year | Club | NAT | Split | Time | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 398 | Orri Einarsson | 1959 | Hjólreiðafélag Akureyra | IS | 01:09:35 (Hr. 1 (38)) 02:17:35 (Hr. 2 (74)) | 02:24:33.29 | |
| 2 | 397 | Hlynur Hardarson | 1966 | Víkingur | IS | 01:09:35 (Hr. 1 (38)) 02:17:35 (Hr. 2 (74)) | 02:24:34.11 | +00:01 |
| 3 | 508 | Ísak Gunnlaugsson | 2007 | HFR | IS | 01:09:35 (Hr. 1 (38)) 02:17:35 (Hr. 2 (74)) | 02:24:38.43 | +00:05 |
| 4 | 511 | Brynjar Logi Friðriksson | 2006 | HFR | IS | 01:10:10 (Hr. 1 (38)) 02:28:59 (Hr. 2 (74)) | 02:37:22.41 | +12:49 |
| 5 | 396 | Jóhann Friðberg Helgason | 1963 | Hjólreiðafélag Akureyra | IS | 01:10:10 (Hr. 1 (38)) 02:28:59 (Hr. 2 (74)) | 02:37:22.45 | +12:49 |